Friday, March 6, 2009

Review of Documentary: "GREEN"




Summary:
The documentary “Green” by graduate student Laura Dunn has been my favorite documentary so far. It focuses on Cancer Alley, the one hundred-mile stretch of the Mississippi River between New Orleans and Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Cancer Alley got its name because 150 petrochemical plants that lie between the two cities. The film focuses on the problem of Cancer Alley and the local people it affects. By particularly providing evidence of what it is like to live on polluted land, being condemned to illness and poverty and not being able to sell their land.

According to a website I found, “Louisiana is consistently ranked among the poorest states per capita in the country, it has one of the nation's worst educational systems, the highest illiteracy rate, and the lowest proportion of people connected to the Internet. Lastly, one-third of the state's children live in poverty.”

The residents interviewed that live in these towns along the Mississippi are confident that there is a link between their health and the petrochemical plants. The saddest part of watching this documentary was the fact that all the young children were acquiring advance stages of such rare cancers.

Another alarming fact is that these big cooperations keep track of their own data and are suppose to report when there is a problem. I remember them comparing this to turning yourself in for a speeding ticket. Except the side effects of this is a little more intense.

The truth is, that no one can realistically eliminate the products of the petrochemical industry because it supplies the key ingredients used in every single nonorganic product. The big businesses are continuing to make money off Cancer Alley because it delivers 25% of the nation's petrochemical product…



New Terms:
Cancer Alley: is an area along the Mississippi River between Baton Rouge and New Orleans, of Louisiana, which contains numerous industrial plants.

Neuroblastoma: is the most common extracranial solid cancer in childhood and the most common cancer in infancy, with an annual incidence of about 650 new cases per year in the US.

EPA: EPA leads the nation's environmental science, research, education and assessment efforts. The mission of the Environmental Protection Agency is to protect human health and the environment. Since 1970, EPA has been working for a cleaner, healthier environment for the American people.

Louisiana Chemical Industry
: Mission is to improve the quality of life through the power of chemistry.

Environmental racism
: refers to intentional or unintentional racial discrimination in the enforcement of environmental rules and regulations, the intentional or unintentional targeting of minority communities for the siting of polluting industries, or the exclusion of minority groups from public and private boards, commissions, and regulatory bodies.

My thoughts:

As I mentioned in class this whole documentary reminded me of the movie, Erin Brokovich. For those of you who have never seen it here is how it all goes down… Erin Brockovich is an “unemployed single mother who becomes a legal assistant and almost single-handedly brings down a California Power Company accused of polluting a city's water supply. She finds herself in a series of events that would involve her lawfirm in one of the biggest class action lawsuits in American history against a multi-billion dollar corporation.” Except in the movie, they go to court and win lots of money and everyone lives happily ever after. I just wish the same thing could happen with the plants in Louisiana.

This is such a sad situation because I feel that there is nothing we can do to prevent this from happening. I mean I can try and not purchase things made of plastic but that probably wouldn’t last very long. It’s so easy to go on and live your life without considering the damage that these plants are causing when it’s not in your backyard.

A women on the documentary said, “Some people could sell a soul for some green,” and I think that’s true. What do you think? Is there anything we can do to help this situation? Lastly, do you think that environmental racism is an issue in Louisiana?

Here's a link to the Cancer Alley Blog- Check it out!

That’s all, thanks for reading. =)


22 comments:

  1. Hey Shar-
    Great post! I really liked the links you provided throughout your post. I cannot believe the conditions these families are living in. I mean to be called "Cancer Alley" speaks for itself. Hopefully they'll come up with a solution that not only benefits themselves, but the environment as well. Great Job Shar!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great review, Shar! I thought you summarized the film very well. I agree that this is a sad situation and it's frustrating because it does seem impossible for us to give up plastic products. I do think that environmental racism is definitely prevalent in Louisiana, and unfortunately I don't know of any way to help change the situation.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great post Shar. It is so sad how this whole situation is happening, and its hard to think there isnt much we can do about it from here. Except, like you said try to decrease our consumption of plastics, but that is definitely a hard thing to do. Guess just do what we can! Thanks for your thoughts :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice post Shar! I think that there is not a whole lot that we, personally can do to help this issue. I think that a lot of the improvements that need to be made should rest on the shoulders of the corporations that are infecting the area people are calling home. It's true, not only in Louisiana is there a problem of environmental racism but throughout the whole country! I'm sure there are problems like this that exist else where, we just don't hear about it...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Shar-

    Great post! This was also my favorite documentary so far as well! I haven't seen Erin Brocovich but I think I want to for sure now. This situation is really sad, because like you said I don't think there is a lot that we can do... I looked around my room just right now and SO much is made out of plastic, I don't know how I would just exclude it from my life.

    Heather

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great Great post Shar!
    Thanks for the thorough review!!
    This film does remind me a lot of Erin Brokovich!!! I also wish some fairy tale ending like this happened in Cancer Alley. But realistically, I don't think much can be done which is a SAD fact! I feel so bad for those people who are effected and are getting cancer! With our eye-opener though, I know we can make some smarter choices! (like green lip gloss)...but as for SOLUTIONS, I don't know what we can do!!
    and yes, I think that environmental racism is happening in Louisiana because those people living in Cancer Alley are from low-income families! I am glad this movie put the awareness out there, I'm just not sure if anything can be done :(
    Great review! :)

    Kathy

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great job Shar!
    Loved the links as well..really interesting! Decreasing our consumption of plastics is a good place to start with this. One small step can become a huge one!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great Post Shar.
    I do think that some people will sell their soul for some green, and I think this documentary shows a great example of people doing just that. The chemical industries that are aware of what they are doing to the environment and the communities around them continue to produce hazardous materials and pollute the air. Its sad to think about. The industries are sacrificing peoples health and lives to keep their businesses going.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Shar-

    Great review. This is sad to think about because some are suffering while others are benefiting. "Some people could seel their soul for some green" is a statement that I agree with as well. Money is a powerful thing.. and lots of power is a scary thing.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Shar,

    I agree with you that this the best video so far...in addition I like the way that you defined Cancer Ally... I had never heard of this, and it is really just kind of ridiculous that we have actual areas that are able to be define because of the cancer occurrences. Some people could sell a soul for some green... yes I do agree with this statement I think it was evident in the film and I happen to know some people that I believe might take this offer as well!:) Great job shar

    ReplyDelete
  11. Great job Shar! You are totally right that this documentary is like the movie Erin Brokovich, except without the happy ending. I think that what is happening down there is so sad. What these people are going through is totally unfair. I don't know if I like the term environmental racism, because I don't completely believe that that is what it is. I think that the lower income people of Louisiana are totally at the disadvantage, so environmental classism is more like the term I would use. And this isn't just occurring in Louisiana, this occurs everywhere, and I really think that something needs to be done about it.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Shar,
    I was thinking the same thing about the Erin Brokovich movie. You're right it would be very hard to not buy plastic goods for a very long period of time as they are so convenient and are really in about everything that we use. It's sad to me that our government EPA doesn't keep these companies more accountable.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Shar,
    You had a very well-written and thorough review! Great job! It really caught my attention when you stated, "The truth is, that no one can realistically eliminate the products of the petrochemical industry because it supplies the key ingredients used in every single nonorganic product." I think this statement has a lot of truth to it. We are so dependent on plastics that we will probably never eliminate it from our environment completely. The best we can do is gradually try to lessen our dependence on plastic!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hey Shar,
    I'm guessing that Louisiana has never been very high on the state income charts which may have led to these plants being placed pretty much all in one state. I'm sure they figured that since people are very poor around the region that they won't be able to fight back in ways a wealthier state could.

    ReplyDelete
  15. It is harder to take action when one is not directly being affected by this type of situation. We kind of inevitably forget that things like "cancer alley" really exist, because we are not informed enough or we just don't pay attention since we are not affected by it closely. I didn't know anything about this "cancer alley" until I watched this video, and it's very heart-breaking.
    Good job on your review!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Sharralee,

    This is a really good review! The questions you ask at the end are very thought-provoking. I do think some people would sell a soul for some green. Just like people would kill for money...it really is corrupt. I agree with you when you say it almost feels like there's nothing we can do about the issue with cancer alley, because people will buy their favorite products regardless as long as it isn't affecting them directly. I personally think the only way to get people to shape up their behavior is to let them experience what it feels like to live in harsh conditions like some of the people in the movie. Good post shar! I like the map you posted!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hey Shar,
    Good post! All I could think about during this movie was "Not In My Backyard". I thought it was a heart breaking movie, watching little kids suffer from rare disease. I didn't know anything about this cancer alley before this film, you provided some good outside sources as well.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Shar- I went to the cancer alley blog link you provided...it was SO INTERESTING! I really liked the way the "about me" section talked about what cancer alley is, and the "who I would like to meet" section made a VERY bold statement about the people who are taking the brunt of our environmental negligence.
    Like you said your thoughts section, all you can do is try and avoid products that use petrochemicals manufactured in cancer alley. One really hard concept for me to understand is even environmentally friendly products such as organic based lotions and cosmetics are packaged and sealed with plastic. They are shipped to stores in cardboard boxes with little styrofoam peanuts....even by avoiding products that contain the chemicals were still contributing tot he problem through the packaging and shipment of "better" products...
    --s

    ReplyDelete
  19. Shar~
    Great post!! I really liked the photos you all included too, it really added more to the post!! You made a really good point about trying to avoid the products that use the chemicals made in "cancer alley". Keep up the great work!!

    ReplyDelete
  20. Shar-
    I for sure think that people would "sell their soul for green." People these days are so so greedy its sad! I can't believe that Lousianna is ranked the highest for all of those things, such as not being connected to the internet. Also that 1/3 of the children live in poverty. I would believe that after seeing that documentary. I can say that I definitely take my life for granted! Good challenging thoughts!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Nice review! To think that it's actually us that is keeping these companies in business is really sad. Like you said we can try not to use plastics that the company makes but in the long run we wouldn't have much affect, somewhere the government needs to step in and clean it up.

    ReplyDelete
  22. It is bad to think that these companies are supposed to report on themselves for environmental violations. Why would they do this? So, in order to get the environment safer it would be to everyone's advantage to have a legitamite company to do investigating of environmental concerns, such as the chemical factories in Louisiana.

    ReplyDelete